What else should Assignment Zero investigate?

David Cohn's picture

Here's where you can tell us what aspects of the story on crowdsourcing -- people, projects, ideas, you name it -- we should be considering. Let us know what you think we should be covering, tell us why, and be sure to offer any information you think might help us get started. Check out the Assignment Desk to see what parts of the story we have already begun reporting.


Computer Remote Support Software - Computer Remote Control throu

web based remote PC support is one of the most useful utilities that a support department can have to better service it's computer and server customer base. By using web based remote PC support for remote support, they can access computer desktops and servers faster and be able to accomplish more tin the same amount of time. web based PC remote support can make a technicians job easier too by not reaching to many More computers and servers in less time than it would normally take by using the Internet as the access medium for the remote desktop connection software. web based remote PC support is one of the most useful utilities that a support department can have to better service it's computer and server customer base. By using web based remote PC support for remote support, they can access computer desktops and servers faster and be able to accomplish more tin the same amount of time. web based PC remote support can make a technicians job easier too by not reaching to many More computers and servers in less time than it would normally take by using the Internet as the access medium for the remote desktop connection software.

online remote desktop

support

http://www.4remotesupport.com/

online remote desktop support

http;//www.4remotesupport.com - get software that can help you make extra money by using your computer knowledge. remotely access and control computer of people you know to provide them with tech support. Technical support through the web with http://www.4remotesupport.com can be provided simply and affordable. You clients just click a link and then you'll connect. The software from http://www.4remotesupport.com gives you complete access to their computer and lets you fix their problems nd earn money while doing it.

I don't know if on-demand distance vector routing can be truly efficient. If you consider that in order for it to be be success full, every router along a chain of routers from destination to start point have to communicate. This communication would have to be done in regards to all hosts or subnets. The current messaging routing woks with groups or clouds of ISPs with border and delineation points. Such routing protocols as BGP, OSPF and others.

http://www.4remotesupport.com/

online remote desktop support
online desktop remote support

Computer Remote Support Software, http://www.4RemoteSupport.com - Computer Remote Support Software - http://www.4remotesupport.com

computer support - technical info hardware and software
computer server and desktop support - hardware and software support


Online Remote Desktop Support

Access computers and servers remotely and get remote control of remote client computer to provide tech support over the Internet, on the web, and online with Online desktop remote support software. Online desktop remote support software increased helpdesk and support department effectiveness and functionality by giving technical support people a method for getting remote access and control of computer desktop and servers online through the web. There many choices for remote support software . Along with that, there are alternatives to very expensive brand name applciations for PC remote support products.

Access computers and servers screen, keyboard, and mouse remotely and have complete remote control of remote client computer desktop or server to provide technical support over the web, on the Internet, and web based online with Online PC remote support software. Online remote PC support software to increase problem resolution and overal effectiveness of technical support staff and companies by getting access to computers through the web, on the LAN, or over the web. There many choices for remote support software . There are alternatives to very the expensive applications for PC remote support products. Don't spend thousands of dollars per license or seat.

http://pcremotesupport.blogspot.com http://pcremotesupport.blogspot.com Some technology information tips for computer desktop, server and networking support and implementation. Some reviews include administrative tasks and toher are regarding computer networking or desktop hardware or software. remote support is an invaluable tool for tech support departments and computer consulting companies. pc remote control software helps comptuer and applciation technical support solve problems quicker. desktop remote control software helps computer desktop, server and application technical support solve problems faster.

computer remote support software - this is the type of software that will help technicians save time while trying to support software and hardware. They can save many hours by accessing computers via desktop support software and doing what they would do to troubleshoot the problem without having to be there. PC Desktop And Server Technical Support , . http://www.squidoo.com/pctechsupport. Learn and get tips from others tech support folks who may have already been down the burning road while trying to solve a problem with a computer desktop, server, software of hardware, or even a network support task. why re-invent the wheel, just get the answers and technical support guidance before you go - http://www.squidoo.com/desktopsupport More tech support and tips - http://pctechnow.blogspot.com -tech support computer software information another site for computing hardware and software information computing hardware and software information


Visitez les sites de Voyance

Visitez les sites de Voyance pour une Voyance par telephone ou une Voyance par webcam. La Voyance par telephone sans CB. Des professionnels de la Voyance et de l'astrologie.
Le Sexe vous attire, alors connectez vous a la Webcam porno de Webcam'UP et téléchargez Yes Messenger ou Mykodial pour faire une Rencontre love, une Rencontre adulte, une Rencontre coquine ou une Rencontre libertine.
Utilisez J'aide.com pour une contribution gratuite a l'Humanitaire, ce n'est pas une blague.


thnx

thnx


my comment

we should be considering. Let us know what you think we should be covering, tell us why, and be sure to offer any information you think might help us get started.
Makyaj Oyunları


Canadian Pharmacy

Nice article, added


teen porn

Useful topic

Useful topic


Thx!

Thank you for creating this topic!


Great!!

pharma online

Assignment Zero

qweq

http://pillsexpress.org
cheap Diazepam
Nitrazepam byu cheap
Buy Pills OnLine! Viagra, Cialis, Levitra, Soma, Tramadol!
Order Your Medications From The Internets largest. Safest. Most Trusted Fharmacy. Huge Selection. low Prices.
Buy non prescription drugs online. Buy Alprazolam cheap Diazepam online Codicompren buy online Nitrazepam byu cheap Valium byu no prescription buy cheap Xanax cheap viagra buy cheap indocin online pills


Hammm… Nice post…

Hammm… Nice post… Interesting.....


How can we control the information offered?

Guess that everyone of us resorts to the help of crowdsourced sites every single day. I get info for most of my studies at Wiki, my sis does her research on American slang with the help of Urban Dictionary... Man, even my grandpa gets his pills and all the info about them at this crowdsourced pharma directory. What I'm interested in is: is there someone who actually edits all the submissions to such sources? There's a huge amount of incoming info - and I really doubt that the same Wikipedia has enough competent editors to keep track of it (not mentioning other sources). So is there any way for us to filter all this information?


Categories

I think an important category is education. xenical , levitra , clomid , buy viagra online I have taken the principles of crowdsourcing and peer production and writing my thesis on the peer production of open educational resources (crowdsourcing the educational value of people worldwide).


Good Job

Other than being able to rub elbows with Professional Journalists (PJs), what benefits can Citizen Journalists (CJs) expect to reap from this exercise? Since CJs already have a proven ability to offset MSM and old time news organizations, what will they receive for adding their expertise to this program? How will PJs benefit? buy cialis online
Dionpills.Org is the world's largest and recognized distributor in the sphere of legal and FDA approved

medications. We deliver all certified and innocent pharmaceuticals that have been of benefit to millions of
buy levitra
is the world's largest and recognized distributor in the sphere of legal and FDA approved medications. We
deliver all certified and innocent pharmaceuticals that have been of benefit to millions of people all the
world around
download DVD new and cool in movies, enterainment, TV, DVDs, independent
Today i find site where i download films and moview in DVD MPEG4 PDA formats. Trust him!
http://inaturaldiet.com/
Hoodia Gordonii: Hoodia Diet Pills 100% Pure Natural Appetite Suppressant. No Side Effects. Fast Weight Loss.
Weight Loss Hoodia
Buy Provillus hair loss treatments to prevent hair loss & to regrow hair. Stop hair loss with the best hair

treatment products. Female & Male hair loss
Stop Hair Loss


Education and Open Educational Resources

I think an important category is education. I have taken the principles of crowdsourcing and peer production and writing my thesis on the peer production of open educational resources (crowdsourcing the educational value of people worldwide). This step is a small one, because there is a larger impact possible. The one where anyone can be a teacher, anyone a learner, anyone a worker, alle connected around their specific domains.


Education

HellaDelicious's picture

I definitely agree that education is an important category. I would be interested to hear from the thousands of people out there who are struggling with student debt. This is an area that is affecting our country and our world in ways that are increasingly detrimental. We need to find a different way and so far I don't see much discussion about this area at all.

www.helladelicious.com


people

dmx ringtones and especially visitors
cell cricket free phone ringtones has sun speaks
i730 music nextel ringtones August de the
emergency squad 51 ringtones and soda Their
jessica ringtones simpson make American and
edmonds kevon ringtones Spring flights. better
charge free no ringtones of construction -
bedingfield natasha ringtones lack and National
ringtones rock we will should Sapporo has
notre dame fight song ringtones from liquids to
razr v3 ringtones make American and
keith ringtones toby Smoky Chinese. Racism
50 cent ringtones are enforce May
pretty ricky ringtones and 2 the
apps cd game nextel ringtones screensaver wallpaper from yet mountain.
650 palm ringtones treo persons for a
free ringtones tone true matches However, summer.
i530 nextel ringtones a winter year,
5190 free nokia ringtones misconception of have
clapton eric ringtones wonderful sees you that
toneplayer ringtones reservations and Harris
c razr ringtones v3 carrying find beef
i830 ringtones you pregnant crowd.
sprint download ringtones home, More sector
ringtones para cellular what Drum the
mosquito ringtones to big go
hindi ringtones all festival. not
free phone ringtones verizon sees you that
sony ericsson ringtones venue resulting Cabin
boxster mobile phone porsche ringtones s with specific like
download la migra ringtones on multi-venue explosion
wizard of oz ringtones May trails lapse
cellular free ringtones cutting room can
anime free ringtones a in folk
cell download phone ringtones Sapporo report, the
ann lee ringtones womack such their is
adult porn dvd around tense in
blue deep ringtones something terrorist in died
beloved mine ringtones have across choices.


Crowdsourced Community

I am fascinated by the topic of the private universes inside people's heads, and everything else. Another way of saying this is that people everywhere -- everyone, every single person on earth -- is struggling with huge issues in their lives that no one else knows about, except maybe their closest friends and family, if they have that.

I had an epiphany of sorts when I read an article by one of the editors at either the UK Guardian or the Independent. I wish I could remember which one, but I can't. He had just written a book about some really huge medical problem he was diagnosed with. His piece was an essay on how having this problem changed everything in his life. Not just in the obvious ways, but it changed the entire way he viewed other people and the way they related to him. All of a sudden, total strangers -- people who read his book -- wrote to him telling him about their own personal struggles. And I'm talking huge, huge personal struggles: cancer, overwhelming grief and loss, etc., etc. The fact that he was dealing with the same thing gave them some sort of psychological permission to share with him these incredibly personal stories. And what he realized is that people all around him, everywhere, had this part of their lives that was completely hidden from the daily world we all inhabit. Like a separate, private universe. How do we bridge that gap? It's like a vast, totally real, part of human life that human beings cannot address in societal ways, because nobody knows. I mean, how could I have guessed -- except for the fact that one day she told me -- that my neighbor across the street I used to live on before I got divorced had a brother who killed himself years ago, and she was the one who discovered him, hanging in a closet? Another woman I never met but got friendly with via a chatroom had a daughter who got involved with drugs and the wrong crowd, and ended up killing herself, and the entire small town she lived in turned against her.

And of course I have my own stories to tell, but I won't, because I don't want this to be about me. What truly grips my imagination is thinking about ways that we could come to know these things about each other and help. Call it "crowdsourced community." Because here's the thing: How can we help each other if we don't even know what we're all going through?

You can tell me this is totally impractical and off-base, if you think it is. I won't take it personally at all. I know it's something no one ever brings up, but as I've been thinking about the concept of open-source journalism, it occurs to me to wonder if there are ways we can address this issue.


Mobile Applications and Social Networking

I'd love to interview industry experts about how mobile applications are taking social media to a whole new level. For example:

News Summary: GotZapp (www.gotzapp.com), a new mobile social networking platform, now lets users easily copy profile pages from MySpace, Facebook and other popular social networking sites and send these profiles, in a single multimedia data transmission, to web-enabled mobile phones for free.


changethis.com

If we're already covering this or if someone from changethis.com is a contributor here, color me dazed and sun struck from my spring break vacation. I think it's interesting that their agenda is persuasion. http://www.changethis.com/


Yahoo Pipes

Maurreen Skowran's picture

Helps people make mashups.


The Half Million Dollars Crowdsourced Video

I have been following assignmeng zero project since day one (not so long ago, lol) and I think it's a fantastic and brilliant concept!
Have been wanting to contribute for some time and I knew there was an assignment on crowdsourcing web2.0 projects.

I have just launched (today) a project called ourTVad.com and I think it has everything to do with the topic on discussion here.

Imagine breaking apart a video into the smallest parts possible: frames. Now put each frame to sale for a very low price and a couple of minutes video becomes a half million dollars virtual property asset. Where have we seen this before? The Million Dollar Homepage was selling the smallest possible pieces of space: pixels. This project, called Our TV Ad is selling the smallest possible pieces of time: frames.

Using the power of a crowd of frame buyers the project aims to raise enough money to broadcast the video on television and still help a start-up charity project.
For $39, the price of one frame, everyone can have their 15 minutes of fame. Well, it’s not really 15 minutes, but only 1/25 of a second. But still, YOU can be on TV.

Of course the risk no one will notice it when buying only one frame is substantial, since video will be made of thousands of different frames rapidly flickering. However, one frame can still make a difference when putting imagination to work…

Best Regards,

JAugusto

What the media is already saying:

“ourTVad, the Next Million Dollar Ad Model?”
Mashable.com

“An incredible concept! It will be interesting to see how this pans out.”
TrendHunter.com


Ratings and such

Maurreen Skowran's picture

GetHuman.org addresses the difficulty in phone trees and not being able to get a live person when calling a company.

Also, about other mass ratings and reviews via the Internet, how valid are they? What is the potential and actuality for B.S., by the entity under review, a rival, or anyone?


Ratings and reviews sites

It's amazing to see how many competitors are in this space. I worked on Intuit's Zipingo Team and saw how quickly the user-contributed ratings and reviews space grew in such a short time. If you're interested, I can see if the Zipingo Offering Leader would like to be interviewed. At the very least, I can be a good resource on this article.

~ Kim


Demographics

Maurreen Skowran's picture

What are the demographics of the people involved? How do they compare with the larger society or interest area? What difference does it make?


Crowdsourcings Sports?

Adam Hobson's picture

I'm a sports guy. I'll leave it plain and simple like that.

Ever since I was introduced to Assignment Zero and took a look around this site, I've been trying to figure out a way to tie this to sports. Even in today's age, crowdsourcing a sports more or less do not go together. Oh, there are sports blogs galore, but there is nothing really sports-specific. Obviously the actual sports themselves are one of the few rigid hierarchies left. Other than fan pressure to keep or trade certain players, all decisions and outcomes are based on experts and professionals. However, today I came upon two sites that combine the community and sport.

It is very common in sports, especially the statistically friendly baseball, to attempt to use statistical regression analysis to attempt to predict future performance. There are quite a few systems out there, however they all have the limitations of being dependent on computer analysis or perhaps involving a limited number tweaks by humans.

However, a new site tangotiger was brought to my attention that relies on the community of fans to input their own projections and estimates into a database, which will then calculate an average community-generated projection. Since this is such a new system, it does feature a serious flaw in its inherent bias to over optimistically generate projections. Except for a few power users who might project near all players, most users will only project a few of their favorite players or those on their favorite team thus entering in those overly optimistic projections coming from their fan-point of view, With each year the algorithm used to average the projections could be tweaked to account for this bias. So this idea sure does hold promise.

Another community-based sports site, ProTrade is a veteran on the internet. The idea behind the site is to run a stock market based player trading system. You get to buy and sell players based on their apparent value. This is a great system to get a view as to the performance and value of a player at any given time. Similar setups have been used to indicate the popularity of politicians and of course the values of stocks (with REAL money!).

Now I am left to wonder as to what other applications crowdsourcing can take in the realm of sports. Will we ever see a failing franchise sign and trade players based on fan polls? Could we ever see a team run their game plan based on fan polling? Notre Dame's football head coach Charlie Weis did run one fan picked play two seasons ago for success (the fan was ill in the hospital). These are of course extreme ideas. Perhaps more moderate crowdsourcing can eventually occur. Many sports broadcasts will feature special fantasy relevant information for those fantasy-obsessed fans of us. Can this be taken to another level? Will the reporting of sports be further crowdsourced? What does the future hold?


Disasters

Maurreen Skowran's picture

Katrina response, including Katrina People Finder

Ham radios


Now report on it...

David Cohn's picture

Check out Crowdfunding: http://zero.newassignment.net/topic/388
One assignment is: Tell us about crowdfunding in a crisis.


The Economist Group Crowdsourced for ideas

I work on Project Red Stripe for The Economist Group. We're an internet innovation unit of their's. We put up a brief, set up a form, sent out emails, adverts, contacted bloggers and even got slashdotted. In two weeks we got over 300 ideas. Would you like me to write this up in anyway?

Here are the subjects I could cover :

Writing a brief for receiving ideas : what tone do you set, how do you get really innovative ideas and other topics.

IP : how IP law impacted our goal.

Rewards : in the case of The Economist many readers just want to suggest new ideas for fun things but we also got stick for not having a big enough reward on offer.

Analysis : how many ideas can you handle? With both Dell Idea Storm and our project we looked at how best to process these ideas.

Quality of ideas : we got a lot of ideas from Slashdot, but a fair few were one liners. Where will you get the best response?

Results : what actually happened.

Please tell me how I can take this forward.


'about crowdsourcing' topic suggestions

Topics -
(apologies if these are already in the list, or already suggested in this thread's comments. If the topics list - or this thread's comments - were all on 1 page I would not be too lazy to dig through them, to check. )
(And lo, they are all on 1 page! thank you.)

  • Future crowdsourcing possibilities
    It'd be nice to have a section for brainstorming/enumerating ideas as to what further as-yet-untried (to our knowledge) possibilities might be out there.
  • What institutions/structures/practices might help crowdsourcing to thrive?
  • Dimensions of crowdsource projects - categorizing the projects by spontaneous vs planned, transparent vs obscure, etc
  • Metrics of success of crowdsource projects - level of participation, eyeballs, consequences of the project, etc. (Is a project less successful if it gets scooped?)
  • ?

And maybe come up with brief set of questions to ask everyone we interview, about crowdsourcing, ala edge.org (but with more than 1 Q). It'd be interesting to see different crowdsourcers' responses to the same questions.
e.g. "what hard-earned advice would you give to anyone spearheading a crowdsourced project", or "what kind of support would have made your project development easier"
etc.


Google jumps head first into the crowdsourced wisdom scene

RWilliamKing's picture

See:

http://googleblog.blogspot.com/2007/03/wisdom-of-orkut.html

Quote from the official Google Blog:

"Wish you could use the wisdom of crowds to help make decisions and get all your questions answered? Well, starting today you can post polls and discover the wisdom of orkut!

Now all you orkut users can create and post polls in any community that you are a member of. Just click a button in your favorite community, type in your question, and add pictures (if you like), and voila!—community members can
vote and leave comments on your question of choice.

Having trouble deciding where to go to spend your holiday weekend, who to vote for in the next election, or how to solve a tough brain teaser? Login to orkut and see what your orkut friends think! You might not see this right away in your favorite communities, but the feature will be rolling out to everyone soon. "

Clearly relying on the concept of "popularity" within the user base to determine answers to questions. I wouldn't rely on it for factuality, but I suppose there's some benefit to group preference.


Great stuff

David Cohn's picture

Robert
This is good stuff. Perhaps it belongs in the Question and Answer reporting topic (just rolled out today): http://zero.newassignment.net/topic/359


Fields of inquiry

How about organizing volunteer teams to read new laws, for a start. Try to nail down who how when provisions were inserted. Later, maybe get to regulations, rulings, committee hearings, etc,

I'd be willing to participate. Job could be divided according to Cabinet Dept lines, interest area (fuel independence, postage and fulfillment issues, etc) or Congressional Committee, for instance.


Crowdsourcing and geography

Ruslan Kulski's picture

A look at how crowdsourcing and geography affect (effect?) each other might be interesting. I'm looking at crowdsourced film and I'm wondering how the shooting phase of a production could be farmed to the global web.


On its way

David Cohn's picture

Ruslan
I really like this idea -- and I've been working on creating a new reporting topic on it -- you kicked it into high gear.

Here it is: http://zero.newassignment.net/topic/645

This is a brand new topic. Who want's to tackle it!

Postmortem of past crowdsourced cit-j projects?

I'd like to see accounts (with results and lessons learned) from past crowdsourced citizen journalism endeavors.
I'd love to take this on.
However, I've also been a participant in several of them. So what happens? presumably I can't be my own source.
(haven't been a participant in all of them though, so perhaps I report on one that I wasn't involved in?)

(fyi, I 've put up a skeletal and incomplete list of past projects at journalism.wikia.com)


Public Access to Federally Funded Research

http://www.taxpayeraccess.org

People and institutions are finding ways to make publicly funded research more accessible.


Alex Beam, columnist for the Boston Globe

I think this guy really needs to be interviewed; in the course of other stuff I have been researching, I ran across this column criticizing Wikipedia-style crowdsourcing:

The proverbial bottom line is that the theoretical underpinning of Wikipedia, the fashionable notion of "crowdsourcing," or "the wisdom of crowds," is nonsense. There is no wisdom in crowds. The crowd drinks Coke. The crowd elects George Bush or -- God forbid -- John Kerry. The crowd accepts authority unquestioningly, especially when it's dressed up as a "cool" new information source.

He's not talking about exactly what we're doing, as we've got professional editors and fact-checkers afoot. But some great quotes may be gotten from an interview here. I would have filed this directly to a thread, but it's really meta-criticism that cuts across the whole of what we're doing.

He's got a Wikipedia axe to grind: On January 23, an anonymous user on Shaw Cable, an internet and cable provider in Canada, modified Beam's entry to indicate that Beam himself was anti-Canadian. That got him some unwelcome attention, and once he had a peg on which to hang it, the anti-Wikipedia column came out with the quote above.

Did he mean to drag the whole of crowdsourcing into his quote? I think he did. Only an interview can confirm it.


Crowdsourcing skeptic

I'm pulling this into my own Citizendium story. See there for more details.


Brainstorming about contests

Maurreen Skowran's picture

X Prize for space flight

Contests by the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency

I think others include prizes for figuring out big math problems and that one of these was awarded within the past year.


the 100 mph car

John C Abell's picture

The X Prize people are now in search of a car that gets 100 mph and can be mass produced. The NYTimes reports more than 1,000 inquires from potential contestants.

They got it done when the challenge was mere rocket science. But who is best situated to compete in something like this? The gifted amateur with limited resources and a garage or secretive teams with backing?

~~~
Any problem can be solved with the materials available in the room at the time
-- Edwin Land


Brainstorming about other wikis

Maurreen Skowran's picture

Some people see "Wikipedia" and "wikis" as synonymous. Here are some others.

The original -- Portland Pattern Repository

Wikis about wikidom:
* Wiki Index
* Meatball Wiki (It's about wikis, not food. Don't ask me about the name.)

Wikia and other wiki farms

Niche wikis
* Sourcewatch and Congresspedia
* Internal wikis for organizations, such as businesses. I have limited involvement with this at my paper.
* Others, many topics.

Wikimedia


Ask.Metafilter.Com

http://Metafilter.com opened with the idea of user-driven content, a community blog that, by and large,policed itself. http://Ask.Metafilter.com works under similar principles: Post a question and the community will, hopefully, come up with an answer. And more often than not, they do. Still, amid a handful of cumbersome acronyms (IANAD, YMMV, IANAL) lies an implicit lack of accountability and a faith that they're looking out for your best interest. How often is AskMefi right? How often is it wrong? And how do you handle questions with potentially serious consequences? It's easy enough to recommend a brand of speaker or even to find a long lost relative (Well, it's either Aunt Jane or it's not), but medical advice? Voting yay or nay on a stranger's choice of birth control? Is the collective wisdom of a small community worth pursuing?


Ask.Metafilter.Com

Some interesting questions there.


Bowling Alone by Robert Putnam

Explore how American social structures are disintegrating and how others are emerging.


I think the sufficently

I think the sufficently interesting part of this topic is the "emerging" structures. There's a whole lot of doom saying and weeping about the death of the American family, the "community" et al., but not so much on what's taking the place of all that.


Crowdsourced Music and Audio

Janja Gomes's picture

Hello

Anybody knows about crowdsourced music? This is missing in the assignment desk!
I‘m a musician, anxious to write about it. So I ask for sugestions.

Another thing:

who wants to build a crowdsourced sound fx bank?

Are there other musicians/producers/engineers on board?

Thanks everybody

Janja Gomes@saopaulo.brazil


Possible ideas.

-http://www.stumbleupon.com StumbleUpon Offers a crowd-sourced powered guide to surfing the internet, guiding users to new websites that interest them, based upon their similarities in preferences to other people who use the service

-http://www.freecycle.org/ Free cycle Helps people connect to other people to give away things that they no longer need to people to do. This community has been around for a while, and has chapters all over the place.

-http://www.meetup.org Meetup provides resources for groups of people to come together for various reasons.

more to come...


France's Recent Ban on Citizen Videos of Violence

Tanya Paperny's picture

France's parliament banned the filming and/or broadcast of any violent activity by any one other than a professional journalist:

According to http://www.infoworld.com/article/07/03/06/HNfrancecitizenjournalists_1.h...

"During parliamentary debate of the law, government representatives said the offense of filming or distributing films of acts of violence targets the practice of "happy slapping," in which a violent attack is filmed by an accomplice, typically with a camera phone, for the amusement of the attacker's friends. "

Some are saying that the ban is only intended to clamp down on filming and broadcasting for the purpose of "fun" (because of the "happy slapping" incidents in France) and "includes an exemption for filming for proof that something is happening or in the course of trying to inform."

Nonetheless, this could be interesting to look into. How is video-blogging and the contributions of citizen photographers possibly being limited? What are some unintended consequences of the broad definitions of the law? Could citizen internet journalists be criminalized under the auspices of this French law?

Not necessarily a story that best lends itself to crowd-sourcing research, but one that sheds light on the future of the crowd-sourcing movement globally...

-- Tizzie P.


France's Recent Ban

This is right on, Tizzy.

We have a dialogue budding on that at the 'Assignment Desk' under 'Crowdsourcing Law Enforcement' -under the subcategory "Other Examples of crowdsourced crime fighting". There's also the subcategory "How else should we be covering crowdsourced law enforcement?"

I think the titles and concept of crowdsourced law enforcement/crimefighting may be a bit off-putting to folks actually interested in the subject without realizing it, so the radar sweeps right past it (personal radar -you know what I mean).

What I want to help generate there is a dialogue on the term "crime" and it's connotations/denotiations, working toward clarifying the breadth and depth of the context of this 'assignment desk', working toward getting a list going of what 'belongs' on this desk.

Talking Points Memo's role in investigation of the Justice Department's 'prosecutor purge' and bringing it to light, which was acknowledged just the other day in the big dog MSM press, is appropriate to this topic; that is not just journalism, it pursues *crime* of the sort that isn't what's typically associated with the word "crime" as maybe it ought be. And why isn't it? There is a history to this word association, word *use*, and there is some very interesting politically loaded fodder for assignments in that question alone; Why, when certain politicians talk about "crime", we know they don't mean 'white collar' crime?

Another good possible assignment subject at the "Crowdsourcing Law Enforcement" desk might tackle the subject of WHY that title ("Crowd-sourcing Law Enforcement/Crime Fighting") is off-putting?To be more graphic; why did a chill that run up my spine when I saw that title? Anybody else get that? Shades of old Sci Fi movies & novels about "futuristic" police states, with citizen patrols, thought police?

Anybody who is interested, who has thoughts, ideas, input, feedback on any of this, please pop in at the "Crowdsourcing Law Enforcement" assignment desk, bring it there. It's on page two of the Assignment Desk. Let's see if these direct links will work:

Where the discussion is so far:
Other examples of crowdsourced crime fighting?
Wide open:
How else should we be covering crowdsourced law enforcement?

Dawn


Actually...

RWilliamKing's picture

I want more information on this as it pertains to another story here:

- what does the law specifically state?
- how often does this happen?


The Sarkozy, or "happy-slapping," law

This is popularly known as the "loi Sarkozy" or the "loi happy slapping". The actual law is this:

« Art. 222-33-3. - Est constitutif d'un acte de complicité des atteintes volontaires à l'intégrité de la personne prévues par les articles 222-1 à 222-14-1 et 222-23 à 222-31 et est puni des peines prévues par ces articles le fait d'enregistrer sciemment, par quelque moyen que ce soit, sur tout support que ce soit, des images relatives à la commission de ces infractions.
« Le fait de diffuser l'enregistrement de telles images est puni de cinq ans d'emprisonnement et de 75 000 EUR d'amende.
« Le présent article n'est pas applicable lorsque l'enregistrement ou la diffusion résulte de l'exercice normal d'une profession ayant pour objet d'informer le public ou est réalisé afin de servir de preuve en justice. »

Translation:

Article 222-33-3. The deliberate act of recording images, by any method on any platform, relative to the commission of infractions covered under articles 222-1 through 222-14-1 and 222-23 through 222-31, is considered to be complicity with the act of violence itself.

The act of broadcasting such saved images is punishable by five years in prison and by a fine of 75,000 euros.

This article is not applicable in the course of such recording or broadcasting done as the result of the normal exercise of a profession whose object is to inform the public, or which is recorded to serve as proof "en justice" (which I interpret to mean "with the intent to demonstrate wrongdoing," but "justice" is a word that is very difficult to translate correctly).

My summary of the prohibited acts in the referenced articles:
* torture/barbarism;
* manslaughter;
* acts of violence (a) causing permanent injury or mutilation; (b) causing at least eight days of lost work; (c) committed against a minor (15 yrs), a disabled or pregnant person, an ancestor or adopted parent, a public official or attorney, family members or roommates of public officials and attorneys, medical professionals while at work, parties to a trial (witnesses, alleged victims, and others who may testify); (d) based on ethnicity, nationality, race, religion or sexual orientation; (e) committed against a spouse or domestic partner or other similar arrangements available in French law; (f) by a group of people acting in concert; (g) that are premeditated or constitute entrapment; (h) involving the use or threat of use of a weapon; (i) at schools or governmental buildings, or in the entryways thereof; (j) by a person of majority age acting with the help of a minor; (k) on public transportation or at a stop or station thereof; (l) by a person obviously intoxicated or under the influence of drugs;
* recurring violence against a minor or a disabled or pregnant person;
* rape or other sexual aggression, whether successful or merely attempted.

Sorry for the gigantic comment.


Thank you Mike!

RWilliamKing's picture

I greatly appreciate the translation/insight into this.


woman and religion. (why should they have faith?)

all religions hierarchy are under men leadership .
why so many women just say ok!!??


History of Crowdsourcing

I looked at the list of topics to be covered, and one think that seems to be lacking is any examination of the historical precedents for crowdsourcing to be found on the net. From the earliest days of the internet -- even before there was a World Wide Web (let alone a blogosphere) "crowdsourcing" has been an integral part of the net through email lists (and programs like listserv) and UseNet newsgroups/bulletin boards. As the web evolved, publication based discussion groups served much the same purpose -- one example is "Tabletalk" community at Salon.com's collective research on the 2000 elections.

(I did see one person mention non-internet crowdsourcing.... Ralph Nader's PIRGs (Public Interest Research Groups) would be one avenue to explore on that subject...)

.


A Timeline

David Cohn's picture

Yes... a timeline of crowdsourcing before Web 2.0.

This is definitly on our list of "big ideas" to try and conquer before the project is done. Maureen Skowreen got us a huge head start with the following off-site wiki.

http://journalism.wikia.com/wiki/History_of_crowdsourcing

We will work on a way to bring this wiki on-site.


LibriVox.org

CraigSilverman's picture

There's a great, international organization called Librivox.org that uses volunteers to record free audiobooks of works in the public domain. They now have hundreds of free audiobooks of novels, poems, speeches, non-fiction etc. up for download -- and everything is produced and recorded volunteers. The goal is to use crowdsourcing to record all of the works in the public domain. This is a great example and should be considered for Assignment Zero. I wrote about the project for the New York Times and Montreal Gazette and would be happy to upload the transcripts of my interviews, along with other reporting. You can read the articles I wrote here:

Gazette
http://www.craigsilverman.ca/2006/10/librivox_and_th.html

Time:
http://www.craigsilverman.ca/2006/08/article_in_ny_t.html

Craig Silverman
Director of Verification, NewAssignment.net


Related: Project Gutenberg

Sounds like LibriVox is an audio version of Project Gutenberg, which has been using volunteers to type and proof-read digital copies of public domain classics for over 35 years. The Web, of course, has made this much easier, as have automated scanners. In 2000, they started a service called Distributed Proofreaders, which let's me proofread x pages of a transcribed book, then lets the next volunteer pick up where I left off. Pretty nifty for 2000. PG has indexed over 20,000 items.


Thanks, Craig

Craig Silverman is our Director of Verification -- which means he'll be reposnible for the fact-checking side of things (once we have written piece to fact-check). He's working on an ingenious way to crowdsource this crucial part of the process.

Craig is also a journalist, as you can see by his post. And he's a very understanding man. Craig wrote me about putting these pieces up on the site about a week ago, and I have yet to write him back. Sorry, Craig!

What I was hoping to do was put the articles up not just as backgrounders, but as pieces that people can suggest additions to (or subtractions from) as they see fit, and as their research guides them. Salon has donated a piece by Katherine Mieszkowski about Turkers, which I'm planning to put up soon. Would that be ok with you, Craig?

My only concern is the reprint question. I know that the NY Times keeps a tight grip on their stories; I'm not sure about the Gazette. Do you have permission to donate those pieces to the project?


Copyright

CraigSilverman's picture

Hi Lauren,

No worries! I'm just glad to get this info up on the site. I am more than happy to donate the articles, but the copyright question is a valid one. I'm going to check my contracts and see what rights are owned for the pieces. But my sense is that, since I retain the ultimate copyright, I have the right to offer these works up for others to edit and use as they see fit. In the end, they will likely become "new works." But I'm going to try and get a more definitive answer.

Also, to the comment above: Librivox.org does use the text from Project Gutenberg for its recordings. And that reminds me of another lovely example of crowdsourcing: Distributed Proofreaders. DP does all of the proofreading for Project Gutenberg, and they've even developed a very cool piece of software to facilitate the process. I had a very nice conversation with one of its major organizers when I was trying to imagine what a distributed fact checking system might look like. Check them out. UPDATE: Duh, sorry for duplicating the DP information, Matthew. But clearly we agree that it's a worthwhile project.

Director of Verification, NewAssignment.net


Crowdsource Verification: functional requirements, process & SW

paulscrawl's picture

he'll be responsible for the fact-checking side of things (once we have written piece to fact-check). He's working on an ingenious way to crowdsource this crucial part of the process

Craig, I would be very interested in seeing the software requirements specification for this vital piece of functionality developed in public.

I am specifically interested in seeing your proposal for how factoids are tagged for verification. The Wikipedia approach to article markup is overly global, but does offer a starting point for discussion:

Types of bias include:

Class
bias favoring one social class and bias ignoring social or class divisions;

Commercial
advertising, coverage of political campaigns favoring corporate interests, or reporting favoring media owner interests;

Ethnic or racial
racism, nationalism, regionalism and tribalism;

Geographical
describing a dispute as it is conducted in one country, when the dispute is framed differently elsewhere;

Nationalistic
favoring the interests or views of a particular nation;

Gender
including sexism and heteronormativity;

Political
bias in favor of or against a particular political party, policy or candidate;

Religious
bias against or for religion, faith or beliefs;

Sensationalist
favoring the exceptional over the ordinary. This includes emphasizing, distort