Background

Citizendium: The Emergence of Professionalized Crowdsourcing

First, there was Wikipedia: the anarchic, anything-goes, Wild-West style of information gathering and dissemination on the crowdsourced frontier. Now there's Citizendium, where authors are named and editors shape the entries (we might even call it "pro-am"), marrying together open source culture and the culture of academe. It's an encyclopedia written by the crowd, but on very different terms.

As with most all things, it starts with a story of conflict -- a story of disagreement between two people. Jimmy Wales (Wikipedia) and Larry Sanger (Citizendium) shared a vision of free and accessible information, an ever-growning self-refining encyclopedia of whatever the crowd could imagine. But how would accuracy be ensured? How would the site be policed? Who would be credited for their work, and how?

There was a split, or as contributor Michael Ho has written "Citizendium became less of a fork, and more of a knife." Wikipedia emerged as the very standard of the wise crowd -- and the unwise crowd. Now Citizendium is gearing up to launch as an alternative.


Team Reporting

Want to contribute? Find an assignment on the right and use the "report here" tab. If you have more questions, check out our FAQ.

Want to contribute? Find an assignment on the right and use the "report here" tab. If you have more questions, check out our FAQ.

ReportingSubmitted byPosted
Open Source Journalism: From Nupedia, to Wikipedia, to Citizendium brainopera1 year 10 weeks ago
Interview with Dr. Alex Halavais (Open Journalism Expert) brainopera1 year 10 weeks ago
Matei email Q&A Anna Haynes1 year 11 weeks ago
Redfield email Q&A Anna Haynes1 year 11 weeks ago
Draft 2.1 (spiked) Michael Ho1 year 11 weeks ago
Draft 3 (proposed) Draft 2 version with Britannica comments inserted Randy Burge1 year 12 weeks ago
Encyclopedia Britannica: Side bar: Fights at the OK Encyclopedia Randy Burge1 year 12 weeks ago
Draft 2 Michael Ho1 year 12 weeks ago
Cite PEW's recent detailed data on Wikipedia which challenge Citizendium paulscrawl1 year 12 weeks ago
Eduzendium revision - my kingdom for a wiki Anna Haynes1 year 12 weeks ago
Recast of final paragraphs Michael Ho1 year 12 weeks ago
this is where we really need a wiki... Anna Haynes1 year 12 weeks ago
Eduzendium, redux Michael Ho1 year 12 weeks ago
Eduzendium Anna Haynes1 year 12 weeks ago
Quote regarding the Real Names policy derekpoore1 year 12 weeks ago
alternative "wikipedia is useful as a starting point" quote Anna Haynes1 year 12 weeks ago
Seth F section needs reworking - now 3 corrections Anna Haynes1 year 12 weeks ago
interview with Frieda Brioschi, President of wikipedia italia John C Abell1 year 12 weeks ago
WE'VE GOT A DRAFT!!! Lauren Sandler1 year 12 weeks ago
I offer to write the AZ article on CZ. RWilliamKing1 year 12 weeks ago
Interview notes from Nicholas Carr of RoughType Michael Ho1 year 12 weeks ago
Interview notes with David Pennock, PhD, principal research scientist at Yahoo! Research Michael Ho1 year 12 weeks ago
CZ v. WP: some esoteric terms jteischeid@yahoo.com1 year 12 weeks ago
Citizendium and Wikipedia Head to Head JJackUnrau1 year 12 weeks ago
On language David Cohn1 year 12 weeks ago
Expertise and accountability are not spectator sports Steve Petersen1 year 12 weeks ago
Citizendium Editorial Council member hasn't heard much about contributing yet Steve Petersen1 year 12 weeks ago
Tom Raftery got an interesting response from Larry Sanger about Citizendium contributors Steve Petersen1 year 12 weeks ago
Josh Catone feels that Wikipedia will prevail Steve Petersen1 year 12 weeks ago
Sarah Tuttle on being a Citizendium constable Michael Ho1 year 12 weeks ago
First drafts Mark_Selander1 year 12 weeks ago
I ask a CZ contributor a question about "the switch" RWilliamKing1 year 12 weeks ago
WP vs CZ: Quick Interface Comparison RWilliamKing1 year 12 weeks ago
WP vs CZ: Images RWilliamKing1 year 12 weeks ago
CZ vs WP on Journalism JJackUnrau1 year 12 weeks ago
CZ vs WP on Hitler JJackUnrau1 year 12 weeks ago
CZ vs WP: on Batman JJackUnrau1 year 12 weeks ago
Using a Wise Crowd to Certify experts?? macirish1 year 12 weeks ago
"Barbara McClintock" article nearly identical in Cz and Wp Anna Haynes1 year 12 weeks ago
Memoir - Sanger quotes on Wikipedia (no anecdotes) Anna Haynes1 year 12 weeks ago
interview result with Jérôme Delacroix, CZ exec committee Michael Ho1 year 13 weeks ago
Renaissance Man? Sean Richardson1 year 13 weeks ago
Questions for Sanger Anna Haynes1 year 13 weeks ago
Memoir - Sanger reflecting on Nupedia (upward counterfactual) Anna Haynes1 year 13 weeks ago
"who founded what" characterizations from near time of origin Anna Haynes1 year 13 weeks ago
Barbara McClintock article - Citizendium no panacea Anna Haynes1 year 13 weeks ago
Summation (WP vs CZ) RWilliamKing1 year 13 weeks ago
From Wales in the Talk RWilliamKing1 year 13 weeks ago
Citizendium VS Wikipedia: The Gloves are Off RWilliamKing1 year 13 weeks ago
Mark Glaser's take on wiki accuracy Michael Ho1 year 13 weeks ago
"Hey, Jimmy. Didn't you just edit me out of history?" Michael Ho1 year 13 weeks ago
Wales "isn't happy about it" Michael Ho1 year 13 weeks ago
Larry Sanger on the Edge: a goldmine of philosophical assumptions to question paulscrawl1 year 13 weeks ago
What people are saying about Citizendium and what Larry Sanger has to say about all that st.francisdrake1 year 13 weeks ago
Business Book Writer Doesn't Think Citizendium Will Take Off Steve Petersen1 year 13 weeks ago
Wikipedian Gnangarra Feels That Even Experts Goof Steve Petersen1 year 13 weeks ago
Sanger's replies, part II Michael Ho1 year 13 weeks ago
Wikipedians mock Citizendium's "Family Friendly" Approach Steve Petersen1 year 13 weeks ago
Hope we don't overlap too much Jeff Muckensturm1 year 13 weeks ago
Danny Zacharias is hopeful for Citizendium Steve Petersen1 year 13 weeks ago
mikebelch defects from Wikipedia to Citizendium Steve Petersen1 year 13 weeks ago
LLJSIMS10 has high hopes for Citizendium Steve Petersen1 year 13 weeks ago
Sanger 2001 predicting the futures of Wikipedia and Nupedia, in Kuro5hin Anna Haynes1 year 13 weeks ago
Lets be nice ian_elwood1 year 13 weeks ago
Can't do this story without the blogosphere weighing in Francine Hardaway1 year 13 weeks ago
Sanger's Why CZ will Succeed essay JJackUnrau1 year 13 weeks ago
the importance of opting out jteischeid@yahoo.com1 year 13 weeks ago
Wikipedia's future Michael Ho1 year 13 weeks ago
Continued: My contribs to Citizendium RWilliamKing1 year 13 weeks ago
I signed up to contribute to Citizendium RWilliamKing1 year 13 weeks ago
The "anti-question" log, part 2 Michael Ho1 year 13 weeks ago
The "anti-question" log Michael Ho1 year 13 weeks ago
Summary of first e-mail exchange with Larry Sanger Michael Ho1 year 13 weeks ago
JW Interview in Tech News (4/14/07) John C Abell1 year 14 weeks ago
Nupedia tried 'expert' editors, too: comb Larry Sanger's memoir for ?s paulscrawl1 year 14 weeks ago
Process of "gentle expert oversight" and real name policy paulscrawl1 year 14 weeks ago
E-mail quote from Seth Finkelstein Michael Ho1 year 14 weeks ago
Result of Alex Beam interview Michael Ho1 year 15 weeks ago
Why the Citizendium Will (Probably) Succeed Muhammad Saleem1 year 16 weeks ago
Vandals Michael Ho1 year 17 weeks ago
How Citizendium became less of a fork, and more of a knife, of Wikipedia Michael Ho1 year 17 weeks ago
How can Sanger's knowledge help us? Michael Ho1 year 17 weeks ago
Talking points from Sanger's October 2006 keynote speech to SDForum Michael Ho1 year 17 weeks ago
Open Source outgrowing its 'granola' roots weitenma1 year 17 weeks ago
Questions for Larry Sanger (Citizendium) Michael Ho1 year 17 weeks ago
Additional Information and Resources Muhammad Saleem1 year 18 weeks ago
Syndicate content